16
2008
A Word from OpenAd’s Key Creative Sarah-Jane Threipland: Being a Woman Creative in a Man’s World
I’ve worked in different creative departments for going on seven years now, and with few exceptions, they have all been saturated by men! According to Aquent, a recruitment consultancy in the Netherlands where I currently work, the makeup of most agencies’ creative departments is still only 5% female. 
Now, to be fair, I chose to work in this industry, and I’m not going to bleat on about how hard it is to be a girl. In all honesty I actually prefer to work somewhere with more men than women. I’ve found you know where you stand in a roomful of men. If someone has a problem with you or your work, they’re much more likely to tell you. You are often listened to, especially if you can offer a different point of view. And I’ve heard from colleagues (off the record) that women can be easier to work with on a large team of men. Women can be more collaborative, don’t have the same ego issues to battle and are more willing to work together, even under stressful pitching conditions.
While looking for inspiration to write this piece about being a woman in a male dominated creative department, I asked others in the industry what their thoughts were… What follows are three typical responses, followed by my commentary.
1. “In my agency it’s all about the ego”
I’ve worked in a few agencies where there have just been too many creative heads. Most of these have been men, and they can sometimes make it very hard to do your job properly when they use different creative teams as stakes in some sort of political war. Would it be the same if women were in charge? I wonder…
2. “I’m the only female creative in a department of 12+”
This is what I call ‘Boys’ club syndrome’ – something I’m familiar with from my last agency. It’s not surprising that girls can sometimes feel left out. Typically this manifests itself in the boys going down the pub, where they talk shop, without inviting any of us. The frustrating thing is that important decisions are made there. To my bemused, ‘when was that decided?’ I am usually only offered blank looks in return.
3. “Can we please get a female creative director?”
This is what I call ‘Self perpetuating idealism’ – If your work is always judged by a majority of men, from the creative director on down, it’s hard to think it won’t make a difference. The thing we all know about advertising is that it’s a very subjective beast. If you’re being judged by men on what men find funny, well it’s just not a fair battlefield for a woman.
Now, the good news: being a woman creative means that you often have a Unique Selling Proposition (USP). I don’t like being put on a campaign just because I am a woman, but if I’m also put on it because I am recognized as a talented creative, then that’s fine by me. My female perspective has made the difference on a few of the campaigns I’ve worked on. Some of the work has been for feminine brands, others for masculine brands where the client has been impressed with a different perspective. I don’t know whether things will change - although new groups such as ‘She Says’ are working towards exactly that, aiming to get more women into and to the top of the digital advertising industry. But even if they don’t, female creatives shouldn’t be discouraged - like anywhere else in advertising, being different makes a great USP. Don’t be scared to use it!



Helga Stentzel, a Russian student from the Central Saint Martins College of Art and Design in the UK clearly got to the heart of the matter in the latest OpenAdTalent pitch that asked students to inspire the world to stop using plastic bottled water. Her winning idea ‘Bottled Water: What you really pay for’ convinced the judges and earned Helga a 500 USD prize and moved the Central Saint Martins College of Art and Design up the rankings to third place on the OpenAdTalent University League board.
The latest pitch on OpenAd.net asks creatives to promote Mario - a famous urban R&B singer best known for his 2004 hit single Let Me Love You. What's more, the winner of this pitch will receive 10,000 USD, should Mario's record company choose to license the idea.
Who is Ariel?
Chloe Slade, a student from the University College for the Creative Arts, Farnham, UK has won the latest OpenAdTalent pitch that asked students to create a competition idea for an environmental charity. Her winning idea "Rock Your World" earned Chloe a £250 prize and moved the University College for the Creative Arts, Farnham up the rankings to second place on the OpenAdTalent University League board.
The runner-up spot was taken by a student duo from Central Saint Martins College, University of the Arts London, Sam Haynes and Lee Trott. They received a £100 prize for their idea "Eco-Hub Social Network Application". Both are currently in their final year of advertising classes and were recently hired by ad agency Lowe London. 
Entitled "Using the power of the brand for the power of good," Ogilvy's competition was hosted by OpenAd.net. The competition called for an awareness-grabbing, Cause Related Marketing campaigns with global appeal. They were to benefit a larger cause to be brought to life through branded content for any one or more of Ogilvy's brands, including Ford, BP, American Express, Dove, and Fanta. In recent years, by harnessing the power of brands, Cause Related Marketing has been a catalyst in helping a huge number of charities and causes around the world.
It was during a trip to Nepal some years ago that she experienced how devastating contaminated water can be to the lives of the worlds less fortunate. Upon her return, she did some research and discovered a very cost- effective solution to the problem.
The best ideas will usually come to you either in your sleep or while you're out at the pub with friends. In both cases you're most likely to forget them.
Fri, 30.05.2008 05:08
One tip that I have picked up during my studies so far is to keep a small sketch book fill ed with random sketches, [...]